Polly’s loves helping you host your events! From office parties, family gatherings, birthdays, graduations… we can do it all! All of our catering options can be ordered online and are available for pick-up or delivery.
Holiday Mains
Oven-Roasted Sliced Turkey
Includes 2 qt. turkey gravy
$249.99 per pan
Sliced Glazed Ham
Includes 24 oz. ham glaze
$169.99 per pan
Sides & Extras
Pans
- Red-skin Smashed Potatoes
$35.99 sm | $65.99 lg - Smashed Sweet Potatoes
$48.99 sm | $95.99 lg - Southern-style green beans**
$29.99 sm | $56.99 lg
**contains applewood smoked bacon - Homestyle Stuffing
$35.99 sm | $65.99 lg
Quarts & Pints
- Turkey Gravy $11.99 / quart
- Brown Gravy $10.99 / quart
- Cranberry Sauce $7.99 / pint
Rolls
- Dinner Rolls $6.99 / dozen
Individual Dinners
Ham or turkey individual dinners
• May require reheating
Ham or turkey, homestyle stuffing, red-skin smashed potatoes, turkey gravy, smashed sweet potatoes, southern-style green beans**, our zesty cranberry sauce, and a dinner roll.
**contains applewood smoked bacon
Individually packaged. Includes utensils.
Turkey $17.99 each
Ham $16.49 each
Famous Pies
No Preservatives!
+.50 tin deposit on whole pies
Ordering 50 Pies Or More?
Email us at catering@pollyspies.com
Client Gifting Available!
Seasonal Favorites
- Pumpkin* $17.99
- Pumpkin Maple Crunch $18.99
- Pumpkin Dream $22.99
- Pumpkin Praline Cheesecake $31.99
- Pecan*** $18.99
- Dutch Apple*** $19.99
- Gingerbread Dream $19.99
Available 12/2 to 12/24/24
Creams & Specialty
- Banberry®* $19.99
- Banana Cream*** $17.99
- Chocolate Cream $17.99
- Chocolate Silk $23.99
- Coconut Cream $17.99
- Custard $16.99
- Lemon Meringue $16.99
Double Crust
- Apple* $18.49
- Apple Crisp $19.99
- Cherry* $17.99
- Boysenberry $23.49
Cheesecake
- Traditional Cheesecake $27.99
- Fruit Cheesecake $29.99
Bake at Home
- Peach $16.99
- Apricot $16.99
- Blueberry $16.99
- Rhubarb $16.99
- Pie Shell 3 Pack $10.99
- Pie Shell Single $3.99
*no sugar added options available
***contains nuts
****Must sell a minimum of 100 pies.
Pie Fundraising
Available!
Got questions?
Email us at fundraising@pollyspies.com
Continental Breakfast
Cinnamon Rolls Bakery Box (8) $34.99
Our Giant Cinnamon Roll Bakery Box is perfect for your office, church event, or just an easy breakfast with friends and family. Without a doubt the fluffiest, gooiest cinnamon rolls you will ever taste.
Feeds 10+
Muffins Bakery Box (18) $41.99
There’s no simpler way to bring a taste of home with this Bakery Muffin Box. Mix and match with our yummy muffin flavors including Blueberry, Bran, or upgrade to our seasonal muffin. Includes 18 Muffins.
Biscuits & Bumbleberry Jam Bakery Box (20) $34.99
Want something everyone will love? Look no further than our biscuits. These are the richest, flakiest biscuits you will ever taste with our famous Bumbleberry Jam. Includes 20 Biscuits.
Biscuits & Sausage Gravy (20) $29.99
Biscuits & Sausage Gravy $29.99
Fresh Fruit Tray $52.99
Slices of our seasonal fruit to keep things fresh. This is a perfect add on to any breakfast catering meal or great to bring to kids sporting events.
Feeds 15+
Build your own breakfast
Country Fried Steak $139.99
Feeds 25+.
Have it all Skillet $207.99
Feeds 25+.
Scrambled Eggs $49.99
Feeds 25+.
Fresh Fruit $52.99
Feeds 15+.
Breakfast Potatoes $32.99
Feeds 15+.
Buttermilk Pancakes
$39.99/25 or $76.99/50
Banana Macadamia Nut Pancakes
$49.99/25 or $99.99/50
French Toast
$68.99/50 or $99.99/100
Breakfast Meat $68.99/50
Polly’s Boxed Lunches include a full sandwich with bread baked fresh in our Big Red Oven, a side of fresh fruit, and a slice of our Famous Pie or Cookie, all packaged for you in our signature pie box.
Choose your sandwich
or make it a wrap!
Old-Fashioned Chicken Salad
Cookie $11.99 / Pie $14.99
Hand-pulled roasted chicken, walnuts, celery, sweet onions, and mayo on sourdough bread.
Famous Tuna Salad
Cookie $11.99 / Pie $14.99
White albacore tuna, chopped eggs, sweet onions, relish, celery, and mayo on our sourdough bread.
Garlic Aioli Turkey
Cookie $13.99 / Pie $16.99
Slices of freshly oven-roasted turkey breast, garlic aioli, tomatoes, lettuce, and Jack cheese served on our sourdough bread.
Avocado & Friends (Vegetarian)
Cookie $13.99 / Pie $16.99
Sliced avocado, tomatoes, cucumber, sweet onions, lettuce, vegan Gouda cheese, and garlic aioli on kracked wheat bread.
Breakfast Box $11.99
Perfect for that early meeting. Choose between a half Breakfast Burrito or Half Breakfast Sandwich. Includes fruit and a freshly baked muffin.
Choose your Dessert
Freshly Baked Cookie
Chocolate Chip
Oatmeal
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
Double Chocolate
Snickerdoodle
Slice of Pie
Famous Apple
Famous Apple NSA
Cherry
Lemon Meringue
Valid until 10/31/21. One time use. Available for first time business catering orders only. Cannot be combined with other offers. Must email catering@pollyspies.com to place the order.
Create your own lunch
Sandwich Tray $99.99
Your office will love you if you bring in a Polly’s sandwich tray full of freshly made classics! Feeds 12-24 people, comes with 24 halves. Choose from Garlic Aioli Turkey, Avocado & Friends, Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad in increments of 3.
Sandwich & Salad Tray $84.99
Our sandwiches are made with bread baked fresh every day in our ovens and full of high-quality ingredients! Choose from Garlic Aioli Turkey, Avocado & Friends, Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad in increments of 3. Our Salad Tray comes with fresh crisp greens, sliced cucumber, tomato, carrots, roasted corn, red onion, and our house-made croutons. Choose between Buttermilk Ranch, House-made Bleu Cheese, or Balsamic Vinaigrette dressing.
Salad Tray $59.99
It’s not just sweets and treats over here! Choose between our classic Polly’s house salad or Caesar. Both come with house-made croutons straight from our baked fresh every day bread.
Beverages & Extras
Polly’s Gourmet Coffee Tote $23.99
Each 96 oz tote stays warm for up to 3 hours. Includes cups, sleeves, napkins, straws, cream, sugar, & stir sticks. Choose from Regular Blend, Dark Roast, Decaf or Seasonal flavored. Serves 8-12.
Cold Brew Tote $27.99
Our cold brew is made using our freshly roasted coffee grounds and steeped for 24 hours for the richest and smoothest cold brew you’ll ever have! Serves 8-12.
Vanilla or Caramel Cream Cold Brew Tote $33.99
Our cold brew is made using our freshly roasted coffee grounds and steeped for 24 hours for the richest and smoothest cold brew you’ll ever have! Choose from vanilla or caramel cream. Serves 8-12.
Cookie Bakery Box (75) $73.99
We may be biased, but our Chocolate Chip cookies are the best! You really can’t go wrong with any of our 5 flavors. Try them all! Choose from Chocolate Chip Cookies, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, Snickerdoodle, Double Chocolate in increments of 15.
Iced Tea or Mango Iced Tea $21.99
Two half gallons of our freshly brewed iced tea. Choose from regular or mango.
Orange Juice $21.99
Two half gallons of delicious and nutritious orange juice.
Apple Juice $23.99
Two half gallons of delicious and nutritious apple juice.
Lemonade $21.99
Two half gallons of sweet and tart lemonade.
Strawberry Lemonade $22.99
Two half gallons of sweet and tart lemonade combined with real strawberries.